Comments on: That’s Not MY Birthday! https://parables.blog/thats-not-my-birthday/ Sat, 26 Sep 2020 07:23:09 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.2 By: Anonymous https://parables.blog/thats-not-my-birthday/#comment-2104 Tue, 28 Dec 2010 01:07:03 +0000 #comment-2104 well I wrote something but may have not got it posted….

Dear Angela,
Thank you!

Deirdre

]]>
By: Angela https://parables.blog/thats-not-my-birthday/#comment-2103 Mon, 27 Dec 2010 20:53:31 +0000 #comment-2103 Hello Joseph,
I would like to respond to Deirdre, if I may.
We are believers who left the church about 5 years ago at which time we left behind the traditional holidays. Even though Hanukkah is not a commanded feast, we have chosen to observe it because it is historical. Through a small, rough group led by Judah Macabee, Yahweh victoriously and miraculously perserved His people. There is nothing pagan mixed into this celebration. We teach our children that the miracle of the oil lasting 8 days is a legend. We do not make it a substitute Christmas, nor do we exchange gifts.
It is not insignificant that Yahshua was in the colonnade of Solomon during the Feast of Dedication(Hanukkah). The Jews would gather there to celebrate the feast.(John 10:22-23)
Kislev 25 has no relationship to December 25.
Blessings,
Angela

]]>
By: Joseph Herrin https://parables.blog/thats-not-my-birthday/#comment-2102 Mon, 27 Dec 2010 13:34:44 +0000 #comment-2102 continued…

When I find sincere objections and questions arising from some teaching posted, I will labor at great length to bring further light to a matter. I often carry on personal correspondences with individuals that take many hours of my day. I consider it a divine opportunity and privilege to be honored to do so.

Indeed, I am quite willing to correspond with you further as a brother, but the comment field of this blog is not the appropriate place to do so.

As I have often shared, this is a teaching blog, not a discussion forum. The Father has not called me to host a discussion forum. Indeed, I have no desire to do so, recognizing that such forums have many pitfalls. I have written of this at the following link, which I invite you to read.

http://www.heart4god.ws/id357.htm

Rob, the things you wrote in the previous comment have been addressed by this teacher in a number of writings. The most complete writing on the subject of Christmas and Easter is titled "Removing the High Places."

http://www.heart4god.ws/id585.htm

In this writing I share with many Biblical and historical proofs that Yahweh despises mixture. He does not desire that we mix the holy and profane, that we come out of the idolatry of the world and lead holy and separate lives.

You are espousing a contrary view in your comment, and as I am not convinced of your view, I believe it would be irresponsible of me to present an "alternative" opinion. Yahweh has not called us to voice opinions, but to discern His mind and walk in His will.

If you read the presentation "Removing the High Places" and still hold to an alternate view, I am very willing to hear from you as to why. Please provide spiritual reasons, based upon the testimony of the Spirit and the Word of God to you. It is unreasonable to expect someone to change their mind based upon anything less.

May you be blessed with peace and understanding in these days.

]]>
By: Joseph Herrin https://parables.blog/thats-not-my-birthday/#comment-2101 Mon, 27 Dec 2010 13:21:39 +0000 #comment-2101 Dear Rob,

I wish to encourage you to peace, rather than giving into a spirit of offense. I would like to explain to you (as a brother) why I do not post all the comments submitted.

I have written on many occasions that Yahweh has called me to be a teacher to the body of Christ. I fully understand that those things I teach will not be readily received by the majority of Christians today. There are few who are willing to embrace a Spirit led life, for to do so will lead them to a cross, much loss, and suffering.

Many of the subjects I write about are meat, and the immature who are accustomed only to milk, cannot yet receive it. Other teachings offend the religious minds of many believers.

At the same time, there are many sincere objections and questions to the things taught. As I am a man, and therefore fallible, I consider it to be both acceptable and welcome, when a brother or sister has questions or objections regarding a teaching. One thing I look for, however, is a spirit of openness in those who write.

As you know, there are many who would write merely to debate, whose minds are closed. There are also those who would simply cast insults at one who teaches something they disagree with. I believe it is not profitable (will not result in spiritual fruit) to enter into debate with those writing in such a spirit. The Scriptures also exhort us to avoid such communications.

continued…

]]>
By: Anonymous https://parables.blog/thats-not-my-birthday/#comment-2100 Mon, 27 Dec 2010 08:46:00 +0000 #comment-2100 Mr Herrin, I notice that you don't like posting replies that don't agree with your position. It is your blog so I guess it is your prerogative not to post my reply but I personally feel that we can learn from hearing different viewpoints as long as they are respectful. Well anyway, I won't be checking out your site anymore since I don't feel like reading a monologue.

]]>
By: Anonymous https://parables.blog/thats-not-my-birthday/#comment-2099 Sun, 26 Dec 2010 22:26:38 +0000 #comment-2099 Mr. Herrin,
Just curious, there are those who have not celebrated xmas but go on to celebrate hanukah. You listed that in your post as a winter festival (Not My Birthday). What do you say to those Christians who observe hanuka by lighting candles, giving gifts and relating the lights to Jesus? Some Hebrew Roots observers say this is ok and is an alternative to xmas.
Thanks,
Deirdre

]]>
By: Anonymous https://parables.blog/thats-not-my-birthday/#comment-2098 Sun, 26 Dec 2010 18:20:11 +0000 #comment-2098 Wow, it was our first too !! A totally awesome day as we went to a Messianic Jewish Synagogue and had a meal with like minded believers. We don't feel like we missed anything AT ALL.
Sister……b……

]]>
By: Anonymous https://parables.blog/thats-not-my-birthday/#comment-2097 Sat, 25 Dec 2010 18:47:45 +0000 #comment-2097 Yeshua is King, yesterday, today and forever!! Amen!
We have so enjoyed this day like many other days that the Lord has made. We rejoice and are glad in it! (our first non xmas as an entire family, that came in agreement that doing the b-day, xmas thing, would not be pleasing to Him).
Peace,
Deirdre

]]>